BATTAGRAM: Viral footage showing large quantities of felled and processed timber across a mountainous forest area in Battagram has triggered an official investigation into whether tree cutting exceeded sanctioned limits and whether forest officials or local management representatives played any role in possible violations.
The controversy centres on Shamsher Valley in Gantar, Compartment No. 8, in Allai, where images and videos circulating on social media show timber stacked and transported across sections of the mountainous landscape.
The Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Forest Department maintains that timber harvesting in the area was authorised under an approved working plan. Reports citing the department's position say permission covered approximately 360 trees, primarily described as dry, fallen or diseased.
The Climate Lens has not independently obtained the underlying marking or sanction document confirming the 360-tree figure.
What is confirmed, however, is that the scale of concern was sufficient for senior forest authorities to order a detailed inquiry into whether the cutting remained within authorised limits.
What the Forest Department is investigating
An office order issued on November 8 by Muhammad Saleem Khan, Chief Conservator of Forests for Northern Forest Region-II, Abbottabad, constituted a three-member inquiry committee following what the document describes as a viral social-media video regarding forest cutting in Shamsher Valley.
The committee was instructed to identify the location and nature of the activities shown in the footage and establish whether they corresponded with an authorised forest operation.
But its mandate goes considerably further.
Investigators were ordered to physically inspect the entire forest coupe, examine its boundaries and adjoining forest, and compare sanctioned tree markings with the original markings, working plan and departmental records.
They were also instructed to determine whether the trees actually felled correspond with sanctioned markings in their number, species, volume and location.
Crucially, the inquiry was tasked with identifying any “unmarked, excess, illicit or otherwise unauthorized tree cutting” within or outside the approved coupe.
That makes the central issue more precise than the images alone can establish.
The question is not simply how much timber is visible.
It is whether the timber that came out of Shamsher Valley can be reconciled with the trees authorities legally approved for cutting.
From marked trees to timber depots
The inquiry order effectively requires investigators to reconstruct that chain.
Officials were directed to count and measure available tree stumps and reconcile them with marked trees, felled trees, extracted timber, depot receipts and relevant transit documents.
This matters because legally harvested timber does not become untraceable once a tree is felled.
Marking records establish which trees may be cut. Stumps provide physical evidence of what was actually removed. Extracted timber can then be compared with measurements, transport documents and records at timber depots.
If those records correspond, they can help establish that harvesting remained within the sanctioned operation.
If they do not, the discrepancy becomes a matter for investigators.
The inquiry committee has since carried out a field investigation of Compartment No. 8, according to reporting by The News, examining stumps, timber, marking records and transportation and depot documentation.
Its findings will therefore be important in determining whether the striking scenes circulating online represent authorised harvesting, cutting beyond approved limits, or a combination of the two.
Inquiry also examines possible official involvement
The investigation is not limited to counting trees.
The November 8 order specifically directs the committee to determine whether any Forest Department official or Joint Forest Management Committee personnel facilitated, connived in, ignored or otherwise contributed to illegal forest cutting.
The committee was also asked to recommend departmental, legal and administrative action against anyone found responsible and suggest measures to prevent similar incidents.
No such responsibility has yet been established publicly.
The inquiry itself is intended to determine whether violations occurred and, if they did, who was involved.
That distinction is important because social-media footage can show the physical scale of timber extraction but cannot by itself establish whether individual trees were legally marked, whether permits were violated or whether officials facilitated illegal cutting.
Why cutting in a mountain forest matters
The controversy extends beyond the legality of individual trees.
Forests in steep mountain landscapes perform functions that are difficult to see when their value is measured only in timber.
Tree roots help stabilise soil. Forest vegetation affects how rainfall reaches and moves through the ground. Forest ecosystems provide habitat and contribute to local water and soil systems.
Removing substantial forest cover can increase erosion and disturb these functions, although the environmental impact in Shamsher Valley would depend on the actual extent, location and nature of the cutting, facts the inquiry is still attempting to establish.
For communities living in mountainous areas, forest management therefore involves more than deciding how many trees can legally be harvested.
The condition of the wider landscape matters too.
That makes accurate working plans, tree marking and enforcement particularly important where commercial timber extraction takes place alongside community ownership and environmental protection.
The photographs cannot answer the central question
The images circulating from Shamsher Valley are difficult to ignore.
They show substantial quantities of timber spread through the mountainous terrain, including large stacks of processed wood.
But photographs cannot reliably tell us how many individual trees produced that timber.
Nor can an image determine whether a particular tree was legally marked before it was felled.
Those answers have to come from the physical and documentary evidence investigators have now been asked to reconcile.
The controversy therefore presents a straightforward test for the Forest Department.
If the harvesting was conducted according to the approved working plan, the sanctioned markings, stump count, timber volume, transit permits and depot records should tell a consistent story.
If they do not, the inquiry will have to explain why.
Until its findings are made public, claims about the total number of trees illegally felled remain allegations.
What can already be established is that the questions raised by the footage are serious enough that the government's own investigation is looking for exactly the discrepancies the public wants explained.
The next important evidence from Shamsher Valley will not be another viral video.
It will be the inquiry report.
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our journalism.