Climate justice is simple to preach in diplomatic speeches but difficult to deliver when it comes to budgets. The imbalance between Pakistan's contribution to climate change and the consequences it faces is highlighted by the fact that Pakistan accounts for less than one per cent of global greenhouse gas emissions. Yet the damages and economic losses resulting from the 2022 floods exceeded $30 billion, affecting more than 33 million people and creating at least $16.3 billion in reconstruction and rehabilitation needs.
As a result, the international climate order is being put to the test in Pakistan: whether it can uphold the principle of differentiated responsibility or merely acknowledge it in words.
This article explores the imbalance between causes and consequences, the mismatch in climate finance, the debt burden, the legal and diplomatic aspects of the problem, and the need for internal reforms upon which Pakistan's credibility depends. It concludes by presenting a realistic agenda for action.
The human impact of the 2022 floods was devastating. More than 1,700 people lost their lives, while floodwaters inundated approximately one-third of the country. The post-disaster assessment, led by Pakistan's Ministry of Planning with support from the World Bank, Asian Development Bank, European Union and United Nations, identified housing, agriculture and transportation among the sectors suffering the heaviest damage.
These were not merely assets belonging to the industrial elite but the homes, livelihoods and resources of ordinary people.
Nor was 2022 an isolated event. By September 2025, at least 1,006 people had been killed and more than three million people rescued or evacuated during the monsoon season. Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa were among the severely affected regions.
The repeated disasters demonstrate that Pakistan's climate vulnerability is not a temporary emergency but an increasingly persistent challenge.
Climate Finance: Promises Versus Reality
Warm words have not always been matched by action on the international front.
Following the 2022 floods, Pakistan's recovery and reconstruction needs were estimated at approximately $16.3 billion. At the international conference held in Geneva in January 2023, donors and international financial institutions announced approximately $10.9 billion in pledges.
However, pledges are not the same as disbursements, and the resulting financial burden continues to fall heavily on those least responsible for the climate crisis.
The centrepiece of developing countries' demands, established at COP27, was the Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage. Yet its initial financial scale has remained limited compared with the losses experienced by vulnerable countries.
The fund initially set aside $250 million for its start-up financing arrangements covering 2025 and 2026, intended to support eligible developing countries affected by climate-related loss and damage.
This entire amount represents less than one per cent of Pakistan's damages and economic losses from the 2022 floods alone.
The purpose of a fund intended to respond to climate-related losses is undermined when financing remains inadequate and access procedures delay support for affected communities.
The Debt Burden of Climate Disasters
The more troubling dimension is financial.
Following the 2022 floods, Pakistan faced substantial debt repayment obligations alongside the enormous costs of recovery and reconstruction. Financial assistance from international lenders provided some relief, but it did not eliminate the country's wider debt pressures.
Pakistan's dependence on borrowing creates a difficult cycle in which the country must borrow to rebuild after disasters while continuing to repay existing loans.
This burden can be increased when climate finance is provided in the form of loans, even when those loans carry green or climate-related labels.
Debt restructuring and more accessible grant-based adaptation financing could create fiscal space for the Government of Pakistan to allocate greater resources towards embankments, drainage systems and other essential protective infrastructure rather than debt servicing.
The wider question is whether a country already struggling with repeated climate disasters should also be required to finance much of its recovery through additional borrowing.
Legal and Diplomatic Challenges
The legal landscape is complicated.
The decision accompanying the Paris Agreement clarifies that its provisions concerning loss and damage do not themselves provide a basis for liability or compensation.
This has made the legal pursuit of climate compensation difficult, even as vulnerable countries continue to demand greater financial responsibility from major emitters.
However, the international legal discussion has evolved.
The normative case for climate responsibility was strengthened by the International Court of Justice's 2025 advisory opinion on the obligations of states concerning climate change.
The opinion clarified that states have obligations under international law to protect the climate system and that breaches of those obligations may give rise to legal consequences.
Pakistan needs to capitalise on this development through stronger diplomatic engagement and cooperation with other climate-vulnerable countries.
Pakistan's foreign policy approach to climate negotiations has also faced challenges. Greater engagement with groups of countries sharing similar vulnerabilities and development concerns could strengthen its negotiating position.
A coalition of vulnerable states can carry greater weight in international negotiations than a single debt-burdened developing country acting alone.
The Need for Domestic Climate Reforms
Pakistan's case for climate justice would be stronger if its own house were in order.
The 2025 floods in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa again raised concerns about disaster preparedness and the ability of institutions to protect vulnerable communities.
Climate hazards become disasters when people live in exposed floodplains, warning systems are inadequate, and drainage and protective infrastructure fail to meet local needs.
Pakistan also faces long-term risks from changing glacial conditions and water availability, which threaten communities and agricultural systems dependent on reliable water supplies.
The Resilient Recovery, Rehabilitation and Reconstruction Framework (4RF), developed following the 2022 floods, provides an important starting point.
However, climate adaptation must become a central part of national development planning rather than remain an additional component of donor-supported programmes.
Three Priorities for Pakistan's Climate Justice Agenda
Three priorities are crucial for Pakistan in its pursuit of climate justice.
First, Pakistan must demand predictable, timely and grant-based climate finance.
Funding should be made available through accessible mechanisms and delivered quickly enough to address the needs of affected communities. Loss and damage financing must become a foundation for wider climate support rather than a limit on international responsibility.
Second, Pakistan should strengthen its cooperation with climate-vulnerable and debt-burdened countries.
Such alliances could advance demands for disaster-linked debt suspension clauses and debt-for-adaptation arrangements that would provide greater financial flexibility to countries repeatedly affected by climate disasters.
Third, Pakistan must demonstrate domestic seriousness through measurable reforms.
These should include strict enforcement of land-use regulations, greater investment in early warning systems and transparent reporting on the use of public resources.
Climate policy must move beyond symbolic commitments and become part of practical governance and development planning.
Climate justice will not be achieved through goodwill alone. It must be discussed, documented and translated into meaningful action.
Pakistan's case, supported by evidence and the suffering of millions of people, needs to be advanced with confidence, consistency and discipline.
Topics
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our journalism.