ANTALYA: Pakistan has brought a familiar problem back to the centre of global climate negotiations: how can vulnerable countries protect themselves from climate change if doing so leaves them with more debt?
Speaking at COP31 in Antalya, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif called for greater grant-based climate finance and stronger funding for adaptation and resilience, arguing that support for vulnerable countries should not deepen their debt burdens.
For Pakistan, the distinction between receiving climate finance and borrowing climate finance is increasingly important.
The country faces enormous investment requirements across energy, transport, water, agriculture and disaster preparedness while already operating within tight fiscal constraints.
Pakistan's climate plans carry a huge price tag
Pakistan's latest national climate plan estimates that implementing its mitigation and adaptation priorities through 2035 could require approximately $565.7 billion.
The country has committed to reducing projected greenhouse-gas emissions by 50 per cent below its business-as-usual trajectory by 2035.
But the commitment is divided.
Seventeen percentage points are unconditional, while the remaining 33 percentage points depend on international finance, technology and capacity support.
That means a substantial part of Pakistan's climate ambition depends not simply on domestic policy but on whether the international climate-finance system delivers.
Pakistan is not expecting the entire cost to come from foreign grants. Its climate strategy also points towards domestic spending, private investment, public-private partnerships, green bonds, carbon markets and other financing mechanisms.
The difficulty is determining which climate investments can reasonably be financed through borrowing — and which should not be.
Not every climate project can repay a loan
Debt can make sense for investments that generate revenue or measurable economic returns.
A renewable-energy project, for example, can produce electricity and income over many years.
Adaptation can work differently.
A flood barrier protects communities. An early-warning system gives people time to evacuate. Heat-health programmes can reduce deaths. More resilient drainage can prevent urban flooding.
Their economic value can be enormous.
But they do not necessarily generate a revenue stream from which a loan can easily be repaid.
That is why developing countries have increasingly pushed for grants and highly concessional finance for adaptation.
The question is particularly relevant for Pakistan after repeated floods, heatwaves and other extreme-weather events have exposed the cost of inadequate resilience.
A wider argument at COP31
Pakistan's intervention comes as climate finance is emerging as one of the central tensions in Antalya.
Developing countries are being asked to implement increasingly ambitious climate plans while uncertainty grows around future public financing from wealthier economies.
That tension is likely to shape negotiations well beyond COP31.
Climate finance is often discussed as a single number.
For countries receiving it, however, the conditions can matter almost as much as the amount.
A grant, a low-interest loan and a commercial loan may all finance something labelled a climate project, but they leave very different marks on a country's public finances.
Pakistan's message in Antalya is therefore relatively simple.
Countries facing worsening climate risks need investment to become safer.
The question is whether becoming safer should also mean becoming more indebted.
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our journalism.